I’ll just come out and say it–I love Sherlock Holmes. I love the show, Sherlock, and I love the Robert Downey, Jr movies. I loved teaching Sherlock Holmes short stories, and I’ve read a couple of modern interpretations of his story. Sherlock Holmes is an interesting character, though, in that I wouldn’t want to be friends with him in real life. When I really like a character, I usually wish that we could be friends in real life, but Holmes is an exception. He’s cool, but he would be too stressful for my real life.
This week, I read a Sherlock Holmes-esque tale, but this book differed in the fact that I really liked the narrator, and the detective was a bit more lovable.
If you like detective stories, check out Jackaby!
The narrator in this book is Abigail Rook, a young girl who has traveled to America to find adventure and venture out from under her parents’ plans for her. As soon as she gets off the boat in New England, she starts looking for work. A notice for a job as an assistant to a detective leads her to R.F Jackaby’s house. As soon as she enters his house, she realizes that there’s something different about Jackaby. Like Sherlock Holmes, he is an observant detective who is loved and hated by the local police force. But, unlike Holmes, he focuses mainly on supernatural cases–he even shares his house with a ghost and a former assistant who was accidentally turned into a duck.
At first, Jackaby is nervous about having Abigail help with his cases (that whole assistant turning into a duck thing really messed with him), but once he realizes that she notices normal details, not extraordinary details like he does, he lets her join the case. Together, they catch a serial killer, who, of course, ends up being not quite what he seems.
I really loved this book. The mystery was great–it kept me turning pages, anxious to figure out what was going to happen. And, like I mentioned before, I really liked Abigail, and I enjoyed how wonderfully weird Jackaby was. The supernatural elements were interesting, and they seemed believable. I hope there are more in this series!
This would be a great mystery for junior high or high school readers! Please check it out!